Sunlit renovated Brooklyn townhouse dining room with an oak table, navy chairs, a pale marble fireplace and a rear window overlooking an enclosed autumn garden.

What Clinton Hill's New Townhouse Record Tells Buyers About the Top of the Market

Clinton Hill has a new price record. The house that set it is smaller and plainer than the mansion that held the old one, and it sits a short walk away on the same street. In early October 2026, Curbed reported that 374 Washington Avenue had closed off-market for $9.396 million. The house is a 25-foot-wide 1880 townhouse with more than 7,000 square feet, and each of its five bedrooms has its own bath and walk-in closet. Five months earlier, in May 2026, the roughly 10,000-square-foot Pfizer Mansion at 280 Washington Avenue sold for $7.8 million. In 2021 it had set the prior record at $9.05 million.

If you are comparing Clinton Hill with Fort Greene, Prospect Heights or Park Slope, those two sales tell you more about this market than any median price. At the top of Clinton Hill, buyers have paid the most for a house that is finished and works for daily life, and the larger, more storied houses have repeatedly sold for less than they asked. That pattern goes back more than a decade.

Two houses on Washington Avenue, side by side

Both houses are on Washington Avenue and both are 19th-century townhouses. The figures below come from press reports of each sale.

374 Washington Avenue 280 Washington Avenue (Pfizer Mansion)
Built 1880 1887, for Pfizer co-founder Charles Erhart
Reported size More than 7,000 sq ft Roughly 10,000 sq ft, five stories
Bedrooms Five, each with its own bath and walk-in closet Seven, six full baths plus half baths
Signature features Working fireplaces, Viking stove, central air, decked garden with outdoor bar Restored plaster and woodwork, inlaid floors, stained glass, 19th-century Otis elevator, eight fireplaces, 105-foot parlor floor
Most recent sale $9.396M, off-market, reported October 2026 $7.8M, May 2026

The Pfizer Mansion has the bigger story behind it. Robb Report described a long series of uses after Erhart: a home for his daughter, an annex of the Brooklyn Public Library, a Catholic girls' school. A recent owner then restored it top to bottom, keeping the original plaster moldings and leaded glass and adding a temperature-controlled wine cellar. The house also has a garage reached from Waverly Avenue, according to 6sqft's account of the 2021 sale. On paper it has more of everything than 374 Washington.

How the Pfizer Mansion's price came down

The mansion's recent asking prices show what buyers would and would not pay for. It was listed at $10.35 million in March 2025 and came back that October at $9.4 million, according to Robb Report. It sold in May 2026 for $7.8 million. That is $2.55 million under the first 2025 ask and $1.25 million below what it fetched in 2021.

The house's October 2025 asking price was $9.4 million, the same price 374 Washington reached a year later. Clinton Hill had a buyer at that price, and the house that buyer paid it for was the one down the street with fewer bedrooms and less floor area.

This has happened before. Curbed has listed Clinton Hill's exceptional houses that asked for record prices and sold for less:

  • In 2015, 315 Vanderbilt Avenue, a former union hall that had become an artist's home, set a record at $7.2 million after asking $8.5 million.
  • In 2014, the freestanding mansion at 405 Clinton Avenue asked $9.85 million and sold for $6.5 million. It sold again in 2023 for $5.69 million.
  • The Pfizer Mansion itself sold for $3.2 million in 2007 and came back in 2018 asking $13 million. It reached $9.05 million in 2021.

Curbed called it "the slightly wobbly Clinton Hill mansion market." The houses with the most size and history have kept asking for more than buyers would pay. The record went to a house that was renovated to work for a household.

What the buyer of 374 Washington paid for

The listing brokers told Curbed that the scale and turnkey condition of 374 Washington set it apart in a market short on fully renovated townhouses, as The Real Deal reported. The features in the table point the same way. Every bedroom has its own bath and closet. The house has central air and working fireplaces, and the garden is set up for entertaining. In 6sqft's account, the house's width and depth and its turnkey condition likely contributed to the record price.

The sellers had bought the house for $3.8 million in 2014. Twelve years and an extensive renovation later, it sold for about two and a half times that price. Part of the gain is the Brooklyn market rising. The renovation produced the rest, and buyers here pay for a renovation that changes how a house lives day to day, more than for one that restores how it looked in 1887.

At more than 7,000 square feet, the record price works out to no more than about $1,340 a square foot. The comparison that matters is the surrounding market. In the first half of 2026, one brokerage's figures for the townhouse market covering Clinton Hill, Fort Greene, Navy Yard, Prospect Heights and Vinegar Hill showed a $3.8 million median, a $3.93 million average, and an average of $1,165 a square foot across 37 closings. So the record house sold for more than double the area median, at a per-foot price somewhat above the area average. The premium came mostly from size and condition together. A higher price per foot was a smaller part of it.

The streets behind the avenues

Two different kinds of house on the same few blocks also helps explain the gap. Clinton Hill's Gold Coast was built for wealth that needed staff, horses and carriages. The 1981 designation report for the Clinton Hill Historic District says the Clinton Avenue mansions sat on deep lots that ran back to Vanderbilt and Waverly Avenues. By about 1880, both of those rear streets held carriage houses, stables and service buildings. The same report counts mansions, carriage houses, institutions and apartment houses among the building types that set Clinton Hill apart from neighborhoods made up mostly of rowhouses.

That variety is why the top of this market is hard to price. Park Slope and Carroll Gardens have long rows of similar brownstones, so comparable sales are easy to find. A Clinton Hill buyer at $7 million or more is often looking at a one-of-a-kind house, and its most recent comparable sale may be ten years old and a block away. When good comparisons are scarce, sellers of famous houses have set prices on the house's story. Buyers have paid for how the house works.

What this means if you are buying here

Brooklyn townhouse prices have been rising. The Real Deal, citing another brokerage's market report, put the borough's average townhouse price per square foot at $1,364 for the first half of 2026, up 14 percent from a year earlier. In a rising market, how a house is fitted out still makes a large difference within a single neighborhood. Clinton Hill shows that more clearly than most.

Several practical points follow:

  • The asking price on a landmark house is where talks start. Between 2014 and 2023, the 405 Clinton, 315 Vanderbilt and Pfizer Mansion sales all closed well below the original ask.
  • Count the bedrooms with their own baths. Five bedrooms that each have a bath and closet outsold seven bedrooms in a much larger house.
  • Price the renovation that is still to come. The brokers at 374 Washington said fully renovated townhouses are in short supply. A house that still needs work competes in a different, larger pool of buyers and should be priced that way.
  • Look one block over for comparables. The record and the old record are a short walk apart on Washington Avenue. In Clinton Hill, the right comparison is often the nearest house of the same type, even when it sits in a different price band.

If you are earlier in your search, our guide for first-time buyers of Clinton Hill co-ops and condos covers the apartment side of the neighborhood. Our Clinton Hill neighborhood page has more on the neighborhood.

FAQ

What is the Clinton Hill townhouse price record? 374 Washington Avenue, which closed off-market for $9.396 million, as Curbed reported in October 2026.

What did the Pfizer Mansion sell for? $7.8 million in May 2026. It had asked $10.35 million in March 2025 and $9.4 million that October.

How does the record compare with typical townhouse prices nearby? In the first half of 2026, the median townhouse sale across Clinton Hill, Fort Greene, Navy Yard, Prospect Heights and Vinegar Hill was $3.8 million, at an average of $1,165 a square foot.

Are sellers getting their asking prices for the neighborhood's grandest houses? Recently, not often. In the sales from 2014 through 2026 covered here, the largest and most historic houses have usually closed well below their first asks.

Pricing a Clinton Hill townhouse means reading houses that rarely have a true comparable. The Scott / Robles Team works with Brownstone Brooklyn townhouse buyers and sellers on exactly that kind of pricing. If you are weighing a house on these blocks, or wondering where your own house fits between the record and the median, contact us or start with a home valuation.

Work With Us

Comprised of two partners plus five sales agents and two assistants, The Scott/Robles Team is well-equipped to handle every real estate need with precision and efficiency. They also bring tremendous value with their incomparable white-glove service, and extensive resources including stagers, attorneys, lenders, contractors, movers and others, to streamline every aspect of the process. Contact us today!